North Dakota Fishing and Hunting Forum banner
1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
8,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This was in todays Minneapolis Star/Tribune.

Aggressive measures to control Canada geese proposed
Doug Smith
Star Tribune

Published Mar 5, 2002
Minnesota and other states plagued by burgeoning resident Canada goose populations would be allowed to more aggressively reduce the number of geese under a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposal released Monday.

States would be given broader authority to control the geese by destroying nests and eggs, expanding hunting opportunities and launching trapping and culling programs.

Some of these techniques are already being used in Minnesota and elsewhere, but the Fish and Wildlife Service proposal would provide more options and make it easier for the states to take such actions.

The growing goose population has been blamed for increasing crop damage and for fouling lawns, beaches, waterways, parks and golf courses with droppings. In Minnesota, the resident goose population has quadrupled since the mid-1980s.

Under the more liberal hunting policy being proposed, the geese could be hunted as early as Aug. 1.

More generous hunting methods -- including the use of electronic calls, use of more shells than the current three-shell limit, liberal daily bag limits and expanded shooting hours -- could be allowed during the special August hunts and during existing special early September hunts, which have been offered in recent years to reduce populations.

The regular waterfowl season generally opens in late September or early October.

Each state would determine which, if any, of the measures it would use to reduce goose numbers. Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR) officials said Monday that it is too early to say which options they might use.

"We supported having more latitude to control the goose population, and we'll be looking at some of those tools," said Jeff Lawrence, DNR waterfowl specialist.

However, it is unlikely any of the additional methods will be available until 2003. The Fish and Wildlife Service intends to take public comments on its proposal through May 30, and the proposal probably won't be finalized until fall.

Opposition to plan

Some residents oppose any lethal population control measures for the geese.

Howard Goldman of the Minnesota wildlife organization FATE -- Friends of Animals and Their Environment -- said the Fish and Wildlife Service has overreacted.

"The service has not considered all the nonlethal alternatives to reducing or managing this population," he said. "Their immediate reaction is to initiate an extensive hunting/killing program. We have to find a way to live with wildlife and be more tolerant, rather than look for ways to kill them."

Goldman said his group will fight the proposal.

The proposal targets only resident Canada geese, which are geese that reside and nest in a state, not geese that migrate through the state and nest in Canada. Last spring, Minnesota's resident goose population was 285,000 -- including about 20,000 in the Twin Cities area. That is well above the state's population objective of 182,000.

The Twin Cities area has taken an aggressive approach to containing goose numbers. Annually, about 6,000 geese are trapped and removed from the Twin Cities. Goslings are taken elsewhere and released; adult birds are slaughtered and sent to food shelves.

"Without that kind of effort, it's been estimated that the Twin Cities area would support 250,000 geese -- 10 times what we have now," said Steve Wilds, regional migratory bird chief for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

Running out of room

Last year, a poor nesting season caused the metro goose population to fall by about 5,000, and only 3,500 geese were trapped and removed. But the goose population can increase rapidly. Because of the proliferation of geese elsewhere, officials are running out of places to put surplus metro geese.

The Fish and Wildlife Service estimates that there are 3.5 million resident geese in the United States. About 1.3 million are in the Mississippi Flyway, which includes Minnesota. That number has grown about 6 percent annually.

Hunters have been the main source of population control. Minnesota's goose kill has climbed steadily along with the goose population. The state's Canada goose kill was just 6,200 in 1962, but climbed to a record 231,000 in 1999. Last year, hunters killed about 159,000 Canada geese. The state regularly ranks No. 1 nationally in goose harvest.

Under the Fish and Wildlife Service proposal, states could use the expanded goose-control methods without having to apply for federal permits, as they do now. The states still would have to monitor their spring goose population levels and ensure those numbers don't fall below each state's population objective.

The objective is not to severely reduce the resident Canada goose population, but rather to keep the population in check and try to reduce human-goose conflicts, Wilds said.

"These birds are valuable," he said. "The states want them, but they just want an easier way to deal with them."

-- Doug Smith is at [email protected] .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
791 Posts
I hope that these measures aren't implimented in the Dakotas. In my opinion the geese decoy good enough during the early season,so all they would have to do is raise the limits.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
120 Posts
I agree. I don't agree with destroying nests and eggs. Maybe they should consider some of the same methods that they use for the snow geese like electronic calls and pulled plugs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,219 Posts
I would not like to see E-callers used on the canadas! Like previous posts said "they decoy easy enough".

What I would like to see rather than destroying nests is to increase the bag limits, have earlier and later shooting times (how many times have you had birds come into the decoys after or before shooting hours), be able to hunt water during early season hunts, and open up city limits in certain areas...

Keepin it reel
Madison
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
8,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
The problem is that all seasons and regs. have to be done before the small canadas get here.I think right now that if ND takes a 3 week early season that is subtracted from the late season.So there are lots of geese on the river and no open season.That has to change.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
791 Posts
I, being from the east, would rather have the days in September to hunt the geese. Even if I wanted to hunt that late season, chances are I wouldn't get access. Maybe they should have a split regular season zone for the area around the Missouri river.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
8,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Decoyer...I agree.The early season is statewide and is for everyone.But we should not have to lose days at the end just to have the early season.We should be able to have both.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,326 Posts
I think a possible solution would be to create a "river zone" and either close it to the early season or simply have it open or end earlier. That way the extra time could be used later in the season and the rest of the state wouldn't have to lose part of their season because the geese are never here that late except by the Missouri. I'm not sure what would need to be done to create a zone like this but it could be done. MN uses the same principle to keep parts there that they want open later (metro region and Rochester).

I don't think we have to worry about those extensive measures being taken in ND because MN's situation is a lot different due to the more urban setting. I doubt we'll see lakes being closed due to an excess of bacteria caused by goose droppings. Plus in MN there is a distain for geese by farmers for some reason? They claim loss of crops but I can't imagine it being that high. From all the farmers I've talked to in ND they could care less about geese, it's the blackbirds that they hate. If you ever want to win a farmer over offer to shoot some blackbirds for him! They hate 'em! :smile:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,967 Posts
I think there is no need for the use of a e-caller. Just as Decoyer previously posted, the giant Canadas decoy just fine during early season.
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top