Joined
·
81 Posts
Looking to buy a new all-around predator gun. I'm thinking a 17 HMR, but if I get something like a .243, then i can shoot bear and cougar with it as well. Any suggestions on the two, or any I haven't brought up?
I disagree on the comments about Lions. I think the 243 would be great. Bears on the other hand....... I'd go for more gun. But for the original question, 243 does make a great predator gun. I also would stay away from the rimfires, including the 17HMR. The rimfires make great varmint guns, but not so good on predators.duckmander said:I think you would be fine with one of the .22 cal. center fires for predators. even the 243 would be excellent.
as for bear and cougar. I would want something larger. they would probably get the job done but it would take perfect shot placement. probably in the head. I don't think they would penetrate the vital area very good if at all.
The 17 HMR will take yotes but with a 17 grain bullet too much can go wrong. like wind drift, hit a twig, or grass, don't get me wrong it is a good gun for yotes just not enough for serious hunting. more of a long range squirrel gun.
i wasnt saying you couldnt i was just saying i would not prefer to shoot a bear with a 243.duckslyr said:a 243 will take care of any thing on your list but i would not shoot a bear with one unless i had to. as for mountain lions i know people that shoot them with 17's and 22's every year here in idaho. granted it is after the dogs tree them.